Blog
Bank Fraud Federal Target Letters
Understanding Your Federal Target Letter
First, it’s crucial to understand what a federal target letter means. This is a formal notification from the U.S. Department of Justice indicating that you are a “target” of a federal criminal investigation. In federal prosecutorial terms, a “target” is someone whom prosecutors believe has committed a crime and will likely be indicted, based on substantial evidence linking them to the offense.
This is distinct from being a “subject” (someone whose conduct falls within the scope of an investigation but whose culpability is uncertain) or a “witness” (someone who may have relevant information but isn’t suspected of wrongdoing). Your designation as a “target” indicates that the investigation has reached an advanced stage, and prosecutors believe they have significant evidence.
Contents
- 1 Relevant Laws and Potential Charges
- 1.1 The Bank Fraud Statute (18 U.S.C. § 1344)
- 1.2 False Statements to Financial Institutions (18 U.S.C. § 1014)
- 1.3 Money Laundering (18 U.S.C. § 1956)
- 1.4 Conspiracy (18 U.S.C. § 371)
- 1.5 Mail and Wire Fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1341 and § 1343)
- 1.6 False Entries in Bank Records (18 U.S.C. § 1005)
- 1.7 Structuring (31 U.S.C. § 5324)
- 2 Procedural Considerations
- 3 Immediate Steps and Recommendations
- 4 PART I: UNDERSTANDING YOUR SITUATION
- 5 PART II: APPLICABLE LAWS AND POTENTIAL CHARGES
- 6 PART III: IMMEDIATE ACTION ITEMS AND RISK MITIGATION
- 7 PART IV: DEFENSE STRATEGY CONSIDERATIONS
- 8 PART V: NEXT STEPS AND TIMELINE
Relevant Laws and Potential Charges
Based on the nature of the investigation, there are several federal statutes that may be relevant to your case. I will break these down in detail:
The Bank Fraud Statute (18 U.S.C. § 1344)
This is likely the primary focus of the investigation. The statute has two distinct theories of prosecution:
a) Scheme to Defraud:
- Prosecutors must prove you knowingly created or participated in a scheme to defraud a financial institution.
- They need to show you acted with intent to defraud.
- They must prove the financial institution was federally insured.
b) Obtaining Funds Through False Pretenses:
- Prosecutors must prove you made false statements or promises.
- They need to show these statements were made to obtain money or property under bank control.
- They must demonstrate you acted knowingly and with intent.
Each count under this statute carries a maximum penalty of 30 years imprisonment and a fine of up to $1 million.
False Statements to Financial Institutions (18 U.S.C. § 1014)
This statute is particularly dangerous because:
- It’s easier to prove than full bank fraud.
- Each false statement could be a separate count.
- Prosecutors only need to prove you knowingly made false statements to influence the institution’s actions.
- It carries the same 30-year maximum penalty per count as bank fraud.
Money Laundering (18 U.S.C. § 1956)
If your target letter mentions money laundering, prosecutors are examining financial transactions that occurred after any alleged fraud. They would need to prove:
- You conducted financial transactions.
- The money came from specified unlawful activities (such as bank fraud).
- You knew the money was illegally obtained.
- You intended to either promote illegal activity or conceal the source of funds.
This charge carries its own 20-year maximum sentence per count and often involves extensive financial tracking.
Conspiracy (18 U.S.C. § 371)
If conspiracy is mentioned, prosecutors are investigating connections between multiple individuals. They must prove:
- An agreement existed between two or more people.
- To commit bank fraud.
- At least one overt act was taken in furtherance of the agreement.
This is particularly concerning because:
- Other individuals might be cooperating with prosecutors.
- Communications with alleged co-conspirators could be evidence.
- Actions of others might be attributed to you.
- The statute of limitations might be extended.
Mail and Wire Fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1341 and § 1343)
These charges often accompany bank fraud when:
- Physical mail was used in any part of the scheme (§ 1341).
- Phone calls, emails, or electronic transfers were involved (§ 1343).
Each use of mail or wire communications can be charged as a separate count, potentially multiplying the number of charges significantly.
False Entries in Bank Records (18 U.S.C. § 1005)
This statute becomes relevant if you:
- Made or caused false entries in bank books.
- Issued false bank documents.
- Were involved in bank operations.
Structuring (31 U.S.C. § 5324)
This law prohibits breaking up transactions to avoid reporting requirements. It becomes relevant if:
- Multiple smaller transactions were made instead of larger ones.
- Transactions were just under $10,000.
- Patterns of transactions suggest evasion of reporting requirements.
Procedural Considerations
Several procedural laws and rules are also crucial to your case:
Grand Jury Proceedings (Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 6)
This rule governs:
- What evidence can be presented to the grand jury.
- How testimony can be used.
- Your rights if called to testify.
- Secrecy requirements.
Financial Privacy Laws
Several laws govern how investigators obtained financial records:
- The Right to Financial Privacy Act.
- The Bank Secrecy Act.
- The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act.
These laws might affect what evidence prosecutors can use and could provide grounds for challenging certain evidence.
Statute of Limitations
Bank fraud prosecutions generally must begin within 10 years of the offense. However, this time can be extended if:
- The fraud scheme is ongoing.
- You are a fugitive.
- Additional charges like conspiracy are involved.
Immediate Steps and Recommendations
Given the serious nature of this situation, I recommend the following immediate actions:
Document Preservation
- Preserve ALL documents, both paper and electronic, that might be relevant.
- Do not delete any emails, text messages, or other communications.
- Maintain records of all financial transactions.
- Keep copies of any relevant business records.
Communication Protocols
- Do not discuss this matter with anyone other than me.
- Direct all law enforcement inquiries to my office.
- Do not speak to potential witnesses or co-defendants.
- Avoid social media posts or public statements about the investigation.
Financial Considerations
- Begin gathering all relevant financial records.
- Prepare a timeline of significant financial transactions.
- Document any interactions with financial institutions.
- Identify potential witnesses who might have relevant information.
Cooperation Decisions
We need to carefully consider whether cooperation with prosecutors might be beneficial. This decision will depend on:
- The strength of the evidence against you.
- Potential exposure to multiple charges.
- The possibility of negotiating a favorable resolution.
- The risks and benefits of various defense strategies.
PART I: UNDERSTANDING YOUR SITUATION
The Federal Target Letter
You have received what is known as a federal target letter from the U.S. Department of Justice. This is a serious development that requires immediate attention. In the federal criminal justice system, prosecutors classify individuals in three categories:
- Targets: Individuals whom prosecutors believe have committed a crime and will likely be indicted.
- Subjects: Individuals whose conduct falls within investigation scope but whose culpability is uncertain.
- Witnesses: Individuals who may have relevant information but aren’t suspected of wrongdoing.
Your designation as a “target” indicates prosecutors believe they have substantial evidence linking you to specific criminal activities. This typically means:
- The investigation is in an advanced stage.
- Prosecutors have gathered significant evidence.
- An indictment may be imminent.
- Immediate legal intervention is crucial.
PART II: APPLICABLE LAWS AND POTENTIAL CHARGES
A. Primary Statute: The Bank Fraud Statute (18 U.S.C. § 1344)
This statute typically forms the foundation of bank fraud prosecutions and contains two distinct theories under which prosecutors might proceed:
Scheme to Defraud (Section 1344(1)): What Prosecutors Must Prove:
- A deliberate scheme to defraud a financial institution.
- Knowing participation in this scheme.
- Intent to defraud.
- The institution was federally insured.
Real-World Example: Creating false business records to secure a loan would fall under this section, as would submitting fabricated financial statements to obtain financing.
False Pretenses (Section 1344(2)): What Prosecutors Must Prove:
- False statements or promises were made.
- These were used to obtain money/property under bank control.
- Actions were knowing and intentional.
Real-World Example: Submitting loan applications with inflated income figures or false employment information would trigger this section.
Potential Penalties:
- Up to 30 years imprisonment per count.
- Fines up to $1 million per count.
- Mandatory restitution.
- Asset forfeiture.
False Statements to Financial Institutions (18 U.S.C. § 1014)
Critical Points:
- Easier to prove than full bank fraud.
- Each false statement can be a separate count.
- No need to prove a complete scheme.
- Carries same 30-year maximum penalty.
Defense Considerations:
- Statements must be materially false.
- Prosecutors must prove knowledge of falsity.
- Intent to influence the institution is required.
Money Laundering (18 U.S.C. § 1956)
Prosecutors Must Prove:
- Conducting financial transactions.
- Using proceeds from specified unlawful activities.
- Knowledge of illegal source.
- Intent to promote illegal activity or conceal source.
Key Risk Factors:
- Multiple bank accounts.
- Complex transaction patterns.
- International transfers.
- Cash-intensive businesses.
Conspiracy (18 U.S.C. § 371)
Essential Elements:
- Agreement between two or more people.
- Intent to commit bank fraud.
- At least one overt act.
Special Concerns:
- Co-conspirator statements may be admissible.
- Others might be cooperating with prosecutors.
- Limited defense of withdrawal.
- Extended statute of limitations.
Mail and Wire Fraud (18 U.S.C. §§ 1341, 1343)
Application:
- Each use of mail/wire communications is a separate offense.
- Includes emails, phone calls, wire transfers.
- Interstate commerce element required.
- 20-year maximum per count.
Additional Relevant Statutes:
- False Entries (18 U.S.C. § 1005): Pertains to bank record falsification.
- Structuring (31 U.S.C. § 5324): Involves avoiding reporting requirements.
- Bank Secrecy Act violations: Related to reporting requirements.
PART III: IMMEDIATE ACTION ITEMS AND RISK MITIGATION
A. Critical Immediate Steps
Document Preservation Protocol:
Create a comprehensive preservation system for:
- All electronic communications (emails, texts, social media).
- Financial records (statements, receipts, wire transfers).
- Business documents (contracts, agreements, proposals).
- Communications with financial institutions.
- Tax returns and related documents.
Establish a secure storage system:
- Use encrypted storage for electronic documents.
- Create secure backups.
- Maintain chain of custody documentation.
- Log all access to documents.
B. Communication Management
Strict Guidelines:
External Communications:
- Direct all law enforcement contact to our office.
- No discussions with potential witnesses.
- No social media posts about the investigation.
- No discussions with bank employees.
Protected Communications:
- Use encrypted email for attorney communications.
- Avoid discussing case on personal devices.
- Document all relevant conversations.
- Maintain privilege log.
C. Financial Management
Immediate Actions:
Account Documentation:
- Gather all bank statements (past 5 years).
- Document all significant transactions.
- Collect loan applications and related documents.
- Preserve all communication with financial institutions.
Business Operations:
- Review current financial practices.
- Document internal controls.
- Preserve corporate records.
- Maintain normal business operations unless advised otherwise.
PART IV: DEFENSE STRATEGY CONSIDERATIONS
A. Initial Assessment
We need to evaluate:
- Strength of prosecution’s evidence.
- Potential defenses.
- Exposure to multiple charges.
- Cooperation possibilities.
- Resolution options.
B. Strategic Options
We will need to consider:
- Pre-indictment negotiations.
- Cooperation possibilities.
- Challenge to evidence collection.
- Constitutional issues.
- Jurisdictional questions.
PART V: NEXT STEPS AND TIMELINE
Immediate Actions Required:
- Schedule initial strategy meeting (within 48 hours).
- Begin document preservation protocol.
- Implement communication restrictions.
- Prepare preliminary timeline of events.
- Gather all relevant financial records.