Blog
Can You Get a DUI for Prescription Drugs in New York? What You Need to Know
Late at night, staring at those prescription bottles on your nightstand, you might be wondering if taking your legally prescribed medication could land you in legal trouble. The short answer? Yes, you can get a DUI for prescription drugs in New York. But let’s dig into what this really means for you, because I know this probably isn’t the news you were hoping to hear.
I’ve spent over fifteen years defending clients facing prescription drug DUI charges, and honestly, these cases hit differently than typical alcohol DUIs. There’s often this moment of genuine shock when someone realizes their legitimate prescription could lead to criminal charges. Trust me, I get it – it feels unfair. And you know what? Sometimes I still find myself frustrated by how the system handles these cases.
Understanding Prescription Drug DUIs in New York (Or Trying To)
Here’s something that might surprise you: New York’s DUI laws don’t just cover alcohol. They include any substance that impairs your ability to drive, including those medications your doctor prescribed. The legal term is DWAI/Drugs (Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs), and it’s covered under VTL 1192.4. Though if I’m being completely honest, even after years of practice, I sometimes have to double-check the exact subsections – the law keeps evolving.
When I first started practicing in the early 2000s, prescription drug DUIs weren’t really on anyone’s radar. Back then, it was all about alcohol and illegal drugs. But things have changed so much. I remember this one case around 2010 that really opened my eyes – but maybe I should save that story for a bit later.
Common Medications That Can Lead to a DUI
Not gonna lie, the list might make you nervous if you’re on any regular medications:
- Anti-anxiety medications like Xanax or Valium
- Pain medications, especially opioids
- Some antidepressants
- Sleep medications like Ambien
- Even certain allergy medications (and I’m actually not 100% sure about all the newer ones hitting the market)
I’ve seen cases involving pretty much all of these, though the most challenging ones tend to involve sleep medications. Which reminds me – there was this case last spring that really shows how complicated these situations can get. I know it’s not exactly the same as what you might be dealing with, but bear with me for a second.
The Real-World Impact: A Story That Might Help
Let me share something from a recent case (with details changed for privacy, of course). I had a client – let’s call her Sarah – who took her prescribed Ambien before bed. She woke up disoriented and decided to drive to the store – something she had no memory of later. The officers who pulled her over noted her erratic driving, and despite having a valid prescription, she faced serious charges.
The thing about Sarah’s case that really stuck with me was how the prosecution initially treated it like any other DUI. I’m still a bit annoyed thinking about it, to be honest. They didn’t seem to care that she had no history of substance abuse, no prior arrests, nothing – just a valid prescription she’d been taking for years.
Legal Consequences (Though These Can Vary)
I should probably mention the potential penalties, though I’m trying to remember if some of these changed recently with the latest legislative updates. As far as I know (and you should definitely verify this), first-offense prescription drug DUIs typically involve:
- Fines (somewhere between $500-1000, I believe)
- License suspension (usually 6 months, but this can vary)
- Possible jail time (though in my experience, this is rare for first-time prescription drug cases)
- Mandatory drug evaluation program
But here’s what I’ve learned over the years – and I’m drifting a bit here, but this feels important – the actual outcome often depends more on the specific circumstances and how we present your case than on the standard penalties.
Defending Against Prescription Drug DUI Charges
You know what? I probably should have mentioned this earlier, but there’s something about these cases that makes them uniquely defensible. Unlike alcohol DUIs, where breathalyzer numbers can make things pretty clear-cut, prescription drug cases often have more gray areas.
I mentioned Sarah’s case earlier, and let me circle back because it actually illustrates a key defense strategy we often use. We managed to get her charges reduced significantly by focusing on a few key points:
- Valid prescription documentation
- No prior incidents
- The complexity of medication effects
Speaking of defenses – and I know I’m jumping around a bit here – the People v. Rossi case from 2016 (or was it 2015? These years start to blur) really changed how we approach these cases. The court recognized that having a prescription should be considered as a mitigating factor, though not a complete defense.
What To Do If You’re Arrested
If you find yourself facing prescription drug DUI charges, here’s what you need to know:
First – and I cannot stress this enough – don’t try to explain everything to the officers. I get it, the urge to explain that you have a prescription is overwhelming. But I’ve seen too many cases where this just made things more complicated.
Second, document everything. Keep your prescription bottles, your doctor’s information, pharmacy records – everything. Sometimes these cases come down to tiny details that might not seem important at first.
Looking Ahead
I wish I could tell you exactly how your case will turn out. But one thing I’ve learned (sometimes the hard way) is that every case is unique. What worked for Sarah might not be the best approach for you. That said, I can tell you that these cases are often more manageable than they first appear.
If you’re reading this in the middle of the night, worried about what comes next, try to remember that you’re not alone in this. I’ve helped many clients through similar situations, and while I can’t promise specific outcomes, I can say that there’s usually a path forward that’s less scary than you might be imagining right now.
The legal system’s approach to prescription drug DUIs is still evolving – I see changes almost every year. Sometimes these changes help defendants, sometimes they don’t. But understanding your situation is the first step toward dealing with it.
Remember, this article is meant to give you a general understanding of prescription drug DUIs in New York. Your specific situation might need a different approach. If you’re facing charges, reach out to an experienced DUI attorney who can look at your unique circumstances and help guide you through this.
And honestly? Try to get some sleep if you can. These situations always feel scarier at 3 AM. Tomorrow, you can start taking concrete steps to address this. The legal system might be complex, but it’s navigable with the right help.