Tax Crimes: Understanding Tax Evasion and IRS Penalties

There is nothing wrong with taking legal steps to pay as little tax as possible. However, it is a serious crime to take steps to evade paying taxes. It is also a crime to manipulate the tax system for your own financial gain or the financial gain of others. Let's take a look at why you may be charged with a tax crime, what the penalties may be and how legal counsel may help in your case.

What Types of Tax Crimes Could You Be Charged With?

There are two common activities that the IRS tends to charge taxpayers with. The first is failing to file an income tax return in a timely manner, and the second is failure to report all of your income. Other potentially criminal activities include taking deductions that you didn't have a sound basis to claim or using someone else's identity to file a tax return.

Common Tax Crimes

Tax Crime	Description
Failing to File Tax Return	Not filing an income tax return in a timely manner
Failure to Report Income	Not reporting all taxable income on your return
Improper Deductions	Taking deductions without sound basis or justification
Identity Theft/Fraud	Using someone else's identity to file a tax return
Tax Evasion	Willfully attempting to evade or defeat paying taxes

How the IRS Detects Tax Crimes

The IRS will get copies of any tax forms that you receive from an employer or company that you contracted with in the past year. Your bank, broker or online payment portal may also send paperwork to the government outlining your potentially taxable transactions during the year. This is how it can tell if you are failing to report income or are otherwise making questionable declarations on a tax return.

Sources of Information the IRS Receives

• W-2 forms from employers
• 1099 forms from companies you contracted with
• Bank statements and financial institution records
• Broker statements showing investment income
• Online payment portal transaction records (PayPal, Venmo, etc.)

What Are the Potential Penalties in a Tax Case?

A tax case is either labeled a criminal matter or a civil matter. If the matter is considered a civil case, the government will likely levy financial penalties. These penalties may include the actual balance owed plus interest and a fine. In a criminal tax evasion case, an individual may face a fine of up to $250,000 per count as well as a prison sentence of up to five years per count. It is also possible that a taxpayer will be required to pay court costs and other fees if convicted. The IRS determines if a case is a criminal or civil matter based on your pattern of behavior. If the government believes that you tried to willfully evade paying taxes, it will likely pursue criminal charges.

Criminal vs. Civil Tax Cases: Penalties Comparison

Case Type	Penalties	When Charged
Civil Tax Case	Actual balance owed Interest on unpaid taxes Civil fines and penalties No prison time ⚖ Legal Pulse: Key Statistics 15,000+ Federal Cases Filed Annually 90% Plea Before Trial Statistics based on latest available DOJ data	Mistakes, negligence, or non-willful violations
Criminal Tax Case	Up to $250,000 fine per count Up to 5 years prison per count Court costs and fees Restitution of taxes owed	Willful evasion, fraud, or intentional violations

How Can an Attorney Help In This Type of Matter?

An attorney will attempt to convince the IRS that you did not intend to defraud the government in any manner. This may be done by showing evidence that you had the right to take certain deductions or reported your income in good faith. If an investigation is related to business activity, legal counsel may provide evidence that an accountant or other party engaged in fraud without your knowledge. While this may not be enough to avoid all possible penalties in your case, it could result in the government being more sympathetic to your plight. This may result in a case turning into a civil matter where only financial penalties will be levied. If you can prove that you tried to pay taxes owed in good faith, it may be possible to have penalties and interest waived. That would result in having to pay only the principal balance owed.

Ways an Attorney Can Protect Your Interests

Attorney's Role	How It Helps You
Prove Lack of Intent	Show you didn't intend to defraud the government; can convert criminal to civil case
Provide Evidence of Good Faith	Demonstrate you reported income in good faith; may waive penalties and interest
Show Third-Party Fraud	Prove accountant or other party engaged in fraud without your knowledge
Direct Communication with IRS	Attorney handles audits and meetings; prevents you from inadvertently widening investigation
Build Defense Strategy	Gather necessary documents and construct defense to government's allegations
Negotiate with Government	Work to resolve concerns and potentially reduce penalties

Why You Shouldn't Talk to the IRS Without an Attorney

Your attorney can work directly with the government on your behalf. Therefore, you don't have to attend an audit or any other meeting regarding your case. Avoiding direct contact with the government can be ideal as you may say or do something to inadvertently widen the scope of the matter. Conversely, your attorney will stick to discussing the reasons for the audit and work to resolve any concerns the IRS has in a timely manner.

What to Do If You've Been Audited

If you have been audited by the federal government, it is important that you take the matter seriously. Ideally, you will take a few days to gather necessary documents and meet with an attorney prior to saying anything to the IRS. From there, your attorney can build a defense to the government's allegations and answer any questions that you may have about the case.

Step-by-Step: Responding to an IRS Audit or Investigation

Step	Action	Why It Matters
1	Don't panic; take the matter seriously	Rushed decisions can make situation worse
2	DO NOT speak to IRS without attorney	Anything you say can be used to widen investigation or prove willful evasion
3	Take a few days to gather documents	Tax returns, receipts, bank statements, correspondence needed for defense
4	Meet with experienced tax attorney	Get legal advice before responding to IRS
5	Let attorney communicate with IRS	Prevents inadvertent statements that could harm your case
6	Build defense strategy with attorney	Show good faith, lack of intent, or third-party fraud
7	Work toward resolution	Convert to civil case if possible; negotiate penalties

Understanding the Difference Between Tax Planning and Tax Evasion

There is nothing wrong with taking legal steps to pay as little tax as possible. Tax planning through legal deductions, credits, and strategies is completely lawful. However, tax evasion - taking steps to evade paying taxes through fraud or deception - is a serious crime. The key difference is intent and legality:

Legal Tax Planning vs. Illegal Tax Evasion

Free Consultation

Need Help With Your Case?

Our experienced attorneys are standing by to help. Get a free, confidential case evaluation.

• ✓ 100% Confidential
• ✓ Response Within 1 Hour
• ✓ No Obligation Consultation

Or call us directly: 212-300-5196

Get Your Free Consultation →

Legal (Tax Planning)	Illegal (Tax Evasion)
Taking legitimate deductions	Taking deductions without sound basis
Claiming valid tax credits	Claiming false credits or fabricating expenses
Reporting all income accurately	Failing to report income
Filing returns on time	Failing to file returns
Using legal tax-advantaged accounts	Hiding money in offshore accounts
Working with legitimate tax professionals	Using someone else's identity or creating false documents

When Does the IRS Pursue Criminal Charges?

The IRS determines if a case is a criminal or civil matter based on your pattern of behavior. If the government believes that you tried to willfully evade paying taxes, it will likely pursue criminal charges. Factors that may lead to criminal prosecution include:

• Pattern of behavior showing intentional tax evasion over multiple years
• Large amounts of unreported income or fraudulent deductions
• Evidence of willfulness such as hiding assets, destroying records, or lying to IRS agents
• Sophisticated schemes to conceal income or evade taxes
• Use of nominees or false entities to hide ownership or income
• Failure to cooperate with IRS investigations

Potential Outcomes with Legal Representation

While an attorney may not be enough to avoid all possible penalties in your case, legal representation could result in the government being more sympathetic to your plight. Possible outcomes include:

Best Case Scenarios with Attorney Representation

• Case converted from criminal to civil - Only financial penalties, no prison time
• Penalties and interest waived - Pay only principal balance owed if good faith proven
• Reduced penalties - Negotiated lower fines and reduced balance
• Installment agreement - Payment plan to pay balance over time
• Offer in compromise - Settle tax debt for less than full amount owed
• Case dismissed - If evidence shows no willful intent or third-party fraud

Critical Reminders About Tax Cases

• The IRS receives copies of all your W-2s, 1099s, and bank records - they know your income
• Criminal tax cases can result in $250,000 fines and 5 years prison per count
• Never speak to IRS without attorney representation
• An audit should be taken seriously - gather documents and hire counsel immediately
• Attorneys can convert criminal cases to civil by proving lack of willful intent
• Good faith compliance may result in waived penalties and interest
• Legal tax planning is different from illegal tax evasion

The Importance of Acting Quickly

If you have been audited by the federal government or received notice of a tax investigation, time is critical. Taking a few days to gather necessary documents and meet with an attorney prior to saying anything to the IRS can make the difference between a civil case with financial penalties and a criminal case with prison time. Your attorney can build a defense to the government's allegations, prove you acted in good faith, and work to achieve the best possible outcome for your situation.

Key Takeaways

• Common tax crimes include failing to file returns, not reporting income, and improper deductions
• The IRS receives documentation from employers, banks, and payment portals to verify your income
• Criminal penalties include up to $250,000 per count and 5 years prison per count
• Civil cases result in financial penalties only; criminal cases can mean prison
• An attorney can help by proving lack of intent, showing good faith, or demonstrating third-party fraud
• Never attend an audit or speak to IRS without legal counsel
• Legal representation may convert your case from criminal to civil or get penalties waived