Mississippi Federal Sentencing Guidelines
Contents
What are Federal Sentencing Guidelines?
The Federal Sentencing Guidelines are rules that federal judges use to determine the punishment for people convicted of federal crimes. Established in 1987, the goal was to promote uniformity in sentencing by providing a framework judges could reference. Here’s the key thing to understand: the guidelines provide a range of potential sentences based primarily on two factors:
- The seriousness of the crime
- The defendant’s prior criminal record
So in a nutshell, more serious crimes and more extensive criminal histories translate to stiffer sentences under the guidelines.
Calculating a Sentence Under the Guidelines
Figuring out a sentence under the guidelines is a multi-step process. Here’s a quick overview:
- Determine the base offense level. Every federal crime is assigned a base offense level, which is basically a number that represents the seriousness of the offense. The higher the number, the more serious the crime.
- Factor in specific offense characteristics. This is where the details of the crime come into play. Let’s say it’s a drug case – the type and quantity of drugs involved can bump up the offense level. Or if it’s a fraud case, the amount of financial loss caused by the fraud can increase the level. You get the idea.
- Make adjustments. Now we look at factors that could either increase or decrease the offense level. Stuff like whether the defendant played a major or minor role in the crime, whether they obstructed justice, or if they accepted responsibility by pleading guilty.
- Determine criminal history category. This is based on the number and seriousness of prior convictions. The more prior convictions, the higher the criminal history category.
- Consult the sentencing table. Armed with the total offense level and criminal history category, the judge refers to a sentencing table to find the guideline range, which is expressed in months of imprisonment.
Here’s an example to illustrate:Let’s say a defendant is convicted of bank robbery, which has a base offense level of 20. But he was armed, so that adds 2 levels. And he took $50,000, which adds 2 more. His total offense level is 24. He has two prior felony convictions, putting him in Criminal History Category III. Looking at the sentencing table, the guideline range for an offense level 24 and Criminal History Category III is 63-78 months in prison.
Departures and Variances
Now, an important caveat: the guidelines are advisory, not mandatory. What does that mean? Basically, judges have to consider the guidelines but they’re not bound by them. They can impose a sentence outside the guideline range through what’s called a “departure” or “variance.”A departure is where the judge imposes a sentence outside the guideline range based on certain factors that are specifically laid out in the guidelines themselves. These might be things like:
- The crime involved extreme cruelty or brutality
- The defendant provided substantial assistance to the government
- The defendant’s criminal history is overstated
In contrast, a variance is where the judge imposes a non-guideline sentence based on the general sentencing factors in the federal statutes. This gives judges more flexibility to tailor the sentence to the unique circumstances of the case and the defendant.
The Role of Plea Bargains
In the federal system, the vast majority of cases are resolved through plea bargains rather than trials. And plea bargains can have a big impact on sentencing under the guidelines. Often, plea agreements will include what’s called a “stipulation” – basically an agreement between the prosecution and defense about how certain factors relevant to the guidelines should be applied. For example, they might agree on the amount of drugs involved or the amount of loss in a fraud case. These stipulations can have a big impact on the ultimate guideline range.Plea agreements can also include agreements about departures. For instance, the prosecution might agree to recommend a downward departure if the defendant provides substantial assistance.
Specific Considerations in Mississippi
So how does all this play out specifically in Mississippi? Here are a few key things to keep in mind:
- Mississippi is part of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. This means that Fifth Circuit case law is binding on federal judges in Mississippi when it comes to interpreting the guidelines.
- The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Mississippi, which covers the southern half of the state, has its own policies and practices when it comes to plea bargaining and sentencing recommendations. The same goes for the Northern District of Mississippi.
- Mississippi has a relatively high rate of federal gun and drug prosecutions compared to other states. This means that the specific guideline provisions related to firearms and drug offenses come into play frequently in Mississippi federal cases.
Practical Tips
If you’re facing federal sentencing in Mississippi, here are some practical tips to keep in mind:
- Hire an experienced federal criminal defense lawyer. The federal sentencing guidelines are complex, and having an attorney who knows how to navigate them is crucial.
- Be proactive in gathering mitigating evidence. This might include character letters, records of employment or community service, or evidence of addiction or mental health issues. Your lawyer can use this to argue for a lower sentence.
- Consider the pros and cons of pleading guilty. In many cases, pleading guilty and getting the benefit of a plea agreement can result in a lower sentence than going to trial and losing. But every case is different, so it’s important to discuss this carefully with your lawyer.
- Be prepared for the presentence investigation. After a guilty plea or conviction, a probation officer will prepare a presentence report, which includes a calculation of the guideline range and other relevant information. Review this carefully with your lawyer and be prepared to object to anything inaccurate.
- Understand that the judge has the final say. While the guidelines are important, remember that the judge ultimately decides the sentence. That’s why it’s so important to present the judge with compelling reasons for leniency.