new york penal code 220 46 criminal injection of a narcotic drug
New York Penal Code 220.46: Criminal Injection of a Narcotic Drug
New York Penal Code 220.46 makes it a crime to inject another person with a narcotic drug using a hypodermic needle or other instrument. This law prohibits the non-medical injection of controlled substances into another person. Let’s break down this statute and look at some key aspects.
The Law
According to New York Penal Code §220.46, “A person is guilty of criminal injection of a narcotic drug when he knowingly and unlawfully possesses a narcotic drug and when he intentionally injects by means of a hypodermic syringe or any other instrument into the body of another person without such person’s consent the narcotic drug which he knowingly and unlawfully possesses.”
So in plain English, this law makes it illegal to:
- Possess a narcotic drug unlawfully
- Inject another person with that narcotic drug using a needle or other instrument
- Do this without the other person’s consent
The crime requires that the defendant knew the drug was unlawful to possess and intentionally injected it into another. Accidental injection would not qualify. Consent is also a defense, as the injection must be “without such person’s consent.”
Key Elements
To be convicted under this statute, the prosecution must prove these key elements:
- The defendant possessed a narcotic drug
- The defendant knew this possession was unlawful
- The defendant intentionally injected another person with the narcotic drug
- The injection was done without the person’s consent
- The injection was done using a hypodermic needle or other instrument
The prosecution has to prove each of these elements beyond a reasonable doubt. Let’s look at some of the terms used in more detail.
Narcotic Drug
Under New York law, “narcotic drug” refers to opium, cocaine, heroin, morphine and certain chemical derivatives of these substances. The specific narcotic drugs included are defined in New York Public Health Law §3306. So the drug injected has to be one of these illegal narcotics.
Unlawful Possession
To be guilty under this statute, the defendant must have known their possession of the narcotic drug was unlawful. This means they knowingly possessed an illegal substance without a valid prescription or other authorization. Possessing a properly prescribed narcotic drug and injecting it into the patient would not violate this law.
Injection Instrument
The injection must be done using a hypodermic needle or “any other instrument.” This covers things like syringes, IVs, or other devices used to administer the drug intravenously or intramuscularly. The method of injection is a key element.
Without Consent
If the person injected consents to receiving the narcotic drug, then this crime has not been committed. Consent provides a complete defense. However, consent obtained through coercion or deception may not qualify as voluntary consent under the law.
Penalties
Criminal injection of a narcotic drug is a Class E felony in New York. Conviction carries potential penalties of:
- 1 to 4 years in state prison
- Fines up to $5,000
- Post-release supervision up to 1.5 years
Harsher punishment may apply if the victim is a minor, or if the defendant has prior narcotics convictions. The court also has discretion in sentencing.
Defenses
There are some potential defenses in fighting a charge under this statute. Some examples include:
- Lack of consent: The injection was with the person’s voluntary consent.
- No injection: The defendant did not actually perform an injection.
- No narcotic drug: The substance was not a narcotic controlled under NY law.
- Lawful possession: The defendant had a valid prescription for the narcotic.
- Misidentification: The defendant was mistakenly identified and did not commit the act.
- Duress: The defendant was forced to inject the drug under threat of harm.
An experienced criminal defense attorney can evaluate the details of the case and determine if any viable defenses exist. The attorney can also negotiate with prosecutors for reduced charges or sentencing leniency.
Other charges may apply in addition to a Penal Code 220.46 violation, such as:
- Possession of a controlled substance
- Sale or distribution of narcotics
- Reckless endangerment
- Assault charges
If death or serious injury results from the injection, homicide charges like negligent homicide or manslaughter may also be applicable. Prosecutors can pursue multiple charges against the defendant.
Recent Cases
There have been some recent prosecutions under this statute:
- In People v. Stroman (2021), the defendant injected two minors with heroin multiple times, leading to criminal injection and other charges.
- In People v. Carter (2020), the defendant was convicted after injecting his girlfriend with heroin, causing an overdose.
- In People v. Williams (2018), a man was found guilty of injecting three young women with heroin on different occasions.
These cases illustrate how prosecutors are charging defendants under this statute for non-consensual injections of illegal narcotics.
Public Policy Considerations
There are some policy issues around criminalizing injection of narcotics:
- Deters unlawful distribution of dangerous controlled substances
- Prioritizes victim’s health and prevents injection without consent
- Gives law enforcement a tool to prosecute “drug dealers” who directly inject users
- Potentially deters those struggling with addiction from seeking help
- Raises questions around personal autonomy for consenting parties
The effects of this statute on public health and safety continue to be debated by policymakers and experts.
Conclusion
New York Penal Code 220.46 makes it a felony to unlawfully inject another person with narcotics without their consent. Conviction can lead to years in prison. Defenses like lack of consent and misidentification may be raised. This law remains controversial, but prosecutors continue to charge defendants under this statute for non-consensual, illegal drug injections causing harm.