Virginia Title IX Lawyers
Title IX is a federal civil rights law in the United States that was passed as part of the Education Amendments of 1972. This law prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in any education program or activity that receives federal funding. Under Title IX, sexual harassment, including sexual assault, is considered unlawful discrimination.
In recent years, there has been increased attention and controversy around how colleges and universities handle sexual misconduct allegations under Title IX. Many schools have faced lawsuits from both alleged victims and the accused, claiming the schools mishandled investigations and hearings. This has created a need for experienced Title IX defense lawyers to represent students or faculty accused of Title IX violations.
In Virginia, there are a number of law firms and attorneys that specialize in providing Title IX legal defense services. Hiring a knowledgeable Virginia Title IX defense lawyer can be crucial for anyone facing an investigation or hearing at a Virginia college or university. These attorneys understand the complex Title IX regulations and can advise clients on their rights and options.
Contents
The Role of a Virginia Title IX Defense Attorney
A Virginia Title IX defense lawyer can provide legal counsel and representation for students or faculty accused of sexual harassment, assault, or other sexual misconduct at a Virginia educational institution. Their role may include:
- Advising clients on their rights under Title IX and the school’s policies and procedures. Many accused students are unaware of their rights to due process under Title IX.
- Representing the client in any meetings with school Title IX investigators or administrators. The student has a right to have an advisor present, even though many schools prohibit the advisor from speaking.
- Gathering evidence and preparing a strong defense. This can include interviewing witnesses, collecting documents and electronic evidence, and analyzing the details of the allegations.
- Advocating for the client during any school disciplinary hearings. The attorney can cross-examine witnesses and argue why the evidence does not support a finding of responsibility.
- Negotiating with the school for a fair outcome. In some cases, this may mean pushing for reduced sanctions or avoiding expulsion.
- Filing an appeal if the client is found responsible and the decision is seen as unjust. An attorney can identify grounds for appeal such as procedural errors or new evidence.
- Considering additional legal action if the school mishandles the case. A Title IX lawsuit against the school may be an option in some situations.
Key Laws and Regulations
There are a few key federal laws and regulations that govern Title IX proceedings at colleges and universities in Virginia and across the U.S. Understanding these rules is important for any Title IX defense lawyer.
Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 – This federal law prohibits sex discrimination in education programs receiving federal aid. It applies to all public and private colleges and universities that get federal funds.
The Clery Act – Passed in 1990, this law requires colleges to disclose campus crime statistics and security policies. It also mandates they have procedures for handling sexual assault allegations.
VAWA Amendments to Clery – The 2013 Violence Against Women Act amendments added new rules for school disciplinary procedures in sexual assault cases under the Clery Act.
Title IX Guidance – The Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights has issued guidance documents explaining schools’ Title IX responsibilities, including how to conduct investigations.
VA SB1193 – A 2020 Virginia law requires schools to allow advisors to speak at disciplinary hearings. Many schools had gag orders prohibiting advisor participation.
Key Title IX Defense Strategies
Experienced Title IX defense attorneys employ a variety of strategies and arguments aimed at getting charges dismissed, sanctions reduced, or decisions overturned in Title IX misconduct cases:
Procedural errors – Identifying ways the school failed to follow Title IX or its own procedures, violating the student’s due process rights. Examples include failure to provide proper notice or allow the accused to present witnesses.
Insufficient evidence – Many Title IX cases rely on “he said/she said” claims without corroborating evidence. Effective cross-examination of witnesses can demolish credibility.
Wrong standard used – Schools must use the “preponderance of evidence” standard. Arguments can be made that a higher standard was applied incorrectly.
Credibility concerns – Attorneys may surface reasons why an accuser is not credible, such as mental health issues, bias, or motives to lie. Witness testimony can refute an accuser’s claims.
No harassment shown – The conduct described may not meet the criteria for sexual harassment under Title IX. For example, an isolated offensive remark may not be sufficiently severe.
Free speech issues – Public universities are limited in regulating speech under the First Amendment. Discipline for off-color remarks could violate free speech rights.
Retaliation claims – If the charges themselves are retaliatory, a violation of Title IX, the attorney can work to get them dismissed on those grounds.
Why Hire an Attorney?
Navigating a Title IX investigation and hearing is extremely difficult without knowledgeable legal help. According to one study, students represented by lawyers or advocates were much more likely to be exonerated.